Live Steam in 1/240th Scale

From IBLS
Jump to navigation Jump to search


From Zen.co.uk

Reprinted from the November 1973 Model Railways

A. A. Sherwood records considerations necessary when producing really small scale steamers, like eight-coupled wheelbases of less than one inch!

A. A. Sherwood's K5 at the time of first steam run.

The Problem

In these days of affluence live steamers seem to be getting bigger and bigger. Only a few decades ago 5 inch gauge was really big and most enthusiasts were content with 2½ or 3½ inch gauges. O gauge was called watchmaking and anything smaller impossible. I rather suspect that many of the model loco fraternity are not really model makers at heart but would prefer to work in 4 ft 8½ inch gauge if they could afford it. Being a perverse individual, I have progressed in the opposite direction down through 00 (now called HO), 000 (now called N), to something a little smaller than the recently introduced Z gauge.

Many of my previous efforts were in the toyshop tradition - pot boilers and methylated spirit wick lamps, which were quite effective down to 000 gauge provided one excluded all draughts and could put up with the unsavoury smell of the products of incomplete combustion. It was clear that a new approach was necessary to get down to smaller live steamers. The boiler and firing are the major design problems; the chassis may look much more complicated, but provided the workmanship is sufficiently accurate it will work. The boilers in the three locos to be described are basically the normal loco boiler design taken to its logical limit. In full size we have hundreds of tubes; in 5 inch gauge a dozen or two, so the limit we can go to is one tube, or flue. Now this flue doesn't have to be circular, and it doesn't have to be completely surrounded by water. The basic concept becomes a circular shell with a horizontal division; the top half contains water and the lower half forms the flue. To fire such a boiler, we need a stiff horizontal blowtorch type of flame. Butane, now readily available in a wide variety of packs, is the obvious fuel choice - ask anyone who has had experience with the tantrums of small petrol or paraffin blowlamps. The burner seemed the first item on the largish 'problems to be solved' list.

AASherwood 5699.jpg

The Burner

Figure 1. Burner

The ordinary Bunsen tube is a fairly simple proposition - in the normal sizes. A high jet velocity is essential to get a stiff flame, and some rough and ready calculations showed that the rate of gas flow (i.e. cubic inch per minute) would be minute. I had to think of jets of the order of a "thou" diameter. Experiments with plain Bunsen tubes were disappointing; they had to be very long to get a stable flame - so long, in fact that the end near the jet got blocked with ice due to the cooling effect of the expanding butane! No amount of baffling could be found to make a sufficiently short burner tube which worked. After all, it has to be housed in the tender, and even the "coast to coast" tenders of the Pennsylvania R.R. are of finite length. The solution to the problem required some rethinking. The final outcome can best be described by reference to fig. 1. The volute coil of nichrome wire screwed into the end of the Bunsen tube is the essential ingredient. My analysis of the action is as follows. The wire coil leaks a little of the gas-air mixture at the sides, which produces a fuzzy "halo" of flame round the outside of the coil rather like a "doughnut" (or "donut" if you prefer that spelling) about 4 inch diameter. This keeps the projecting end of the coil at a dull red heat and stabilizes the main flame formed by most of the gas-air mixture which issues from the outer end of the volute coil. There is also probably some effect on the turbulence and mixing due to the shape of the internal surface of the coil, and possibly some catalytic effects as well. Anyway, it works provided that one is very careful to avoid mechanical damage to the delicate coil, and the whole burner is short enough to go in the tender and leave room for the butane tank as well. The capacity of the latter only needed to be about 0.1 cubic inch to run the burner for over 15 minutes. The burner is readily controlled by a needle valve - in fact this is the only control used on the locomotives. Details of the production of the tiny jets will be covered later in this article.

The Choice Of Suitable Prototypes

Having proved that a satisfactory burner could be made, the boiler was the next item of research. It seemed that a suitable prototype should have the following characteristics

1. A tender at least 35 foot long with fairly high sides to house the burner and fuel tank
2. A large diameter boiler, but not too long, since the prospects of blast pipe induced drought were not thought to be good.
3. Big cylinders
4. Big firebox
5. Not a 4-wheel leading bogie.

Since you don't get fat boilers unless the loading gauge is high and wider the obvious place to look is the U.S.A. My first choice was the Delaware & Hudson 4-8-0. (Fig. 2). This satisfied items 1, 2, 3 and 4 of the above list very well. As is seen from the cross section through the second coupled axle, the boiler (or to be precise the casing) is very wide and high. The two front L.P. cylinders are whoppers - 33 inch bore. The H.P. and L.P. cylinders at the back wouldn't have any function in the model. The prototype also had two more cylinders - in the booster on the rear tender bogie - hence the coupling rod on the latter. It did have a 4-wheel leading bogie, but then one doesn't expect the designers of full size locos to consider the model engineers requirements.

The D. & H. also had some 2-8-0 locos with similar boilers, but all these were lopsided two cylinder compounds, with much smaller H.P. cylinders and also external linkage valve gear, whereas the 4-8-0 has poppet valves with little external evidence thereof. I didn't feel inclined to tackle a full external valve gear for my first loco in this scale. In Fig. 2 I have also shown in outline the other two locos I have built in this scale. I will leave it as an exercise for the reader to decide how well or how badly they comply with the five items listed above. The Pennsylvania K5 is the one with [Caprotti valves Caprotti valves] with no valve gear visible externally, which gave me a chance to try internal oscillating disc valves on the model. The trio cover the range from drag speed freight to express passenger steam traction.

Figure 2

Boiler Design

The D & H boiler for the model has the cross section shown in Fig. 2. It looks a poor shape for a pressure vessel but the steam pressure required is low - 15 p.s.i. is more than enough for these midgets. Rough calculations show that the water capacity should be enough for about half a mile run. This assumes no leaks, no condensate waste when starting and dry saturated steam. Even if we allow for wastage of 90 per cent of the water, we should still get a run of about 250 foot. That's about forty laps of the 2 foot diameter test track I had constructed - the track was turned on a lathe with a 4 foot diameter faceplate. Anyway, I don't contemplate going in for any of the now popular efficiency tests with these models!

All the water "drums" of the boilers were made of 0.01 inch thick phosphor bronze sheet, which does not go as soft as copper under the heat of silver soldering. Vertical stays at about 0.4 inch centres support the floor of the drums, and cross stays of tubular form are inserted to take the handrail supports. The lower "pan', which forms the sides and bottom of the flue and firebox is made from 0.012 inch nickel silver sheet. The D. & H firebox floor is rather high, as it has to clear the tops of the driving wheels. The other two have the advantage of lower floors, giving more volume for combustion. The lower pan and water drum meet at the level of the footboards. It will also be seen from the cross sections that extra flue space has been "sneaked" in the last two locos between the coupled wheels and above the axles. This extra flue area is quite significant in the case of a loco with large drivers (80 inch diameter) such as the K5. The main steam-pipe (0.035 inch hypodermic tubing) is connected to the back-head by a barrio union (see Fig. 3). This union is designed to avoid the drilled bolt used in the usual form of banjo union. I don't like drilling long small holes in stainless steel. A 6 inch length of hypodermic tubing in the firebox and flue serves as a steam drier.

General details of the models

Whyte Configuration 4-8-0 2-8-2 4-6-2
Cylinder bore (inches) 0.12 0.10 0.085
Cylinder stroke (inches) 0.12 0.12 0.12
Driver diameter (inches) 0.262 0.280 0.333
Rigid Wheelbase (inces) 0.95 0.90 0.72
Total wheelbase engine (inches) 1.74 1.95 1.90
Total Wheelbase, engine & tender 4.15 4.28 4.08
Overall length, engine & tender 4.60 4.75 4.50
Type of valves piston piston disc
Valve gear eccentrics Walschaerts eccentrics